D’var Torah – February 14
I hope this finds you all well.
When the United States entered World War I in the spring of 1917, it quickly became apparent that America would need the largest army it had fielded since the Civil War, over 50 years before, and a talented cadre of leadership with which to build it. One would naturally have thought that to oversee such an enormous enterprise, President Woodrow Wilson would have appointed someone with decades of military experience as his secretary of war (today’s equivalent to the secretary of the Army and Secretary of Defense). Instead, Wilson appointed a relatively young, short, scrawny, bespectacled lawyer and former mayor of Cleveland, Ohio named Newton Baker to the post. Baker had never spent a day in uniform in his life and many thought he was a pacifist.[1] He was the ultimate outsider, the antithesis of whom many thought would be ideal for this critical position, and as a result, there were those who did not want him there. The following was written of Baker:
“A civilian’s civilian, Baker saw the military as a necessity, but he had no awe of people in uniform, no romantic feelings toward them, and no dreams of glory. …On the day President Woodrow Wilson announced Baker’s appointment as secretary of war, he admitted his ignorance of military matters. ‘I am an innocent,’ he told reporters, ‘I do not know anything about this job.’ But he had a sharp, analytical mind and considerable skill at administration.”[2]
It was this last part that made him so effective and ultimately so successful. He appointed the right people under him, fired those who weren’t making the cut, grew the nation’s military-industrial base, drastically expanded the size of the army, made the vast logistics networks run like a fine-oiled machine, and allowed generals like John Pershing to do the actual fighting.[3] His leadership, in no small part, helped win the war.
Too often in life, we put on myopic blinders. We only listen to someone if they have diplomas from prestigious places, or if their name comes with a title, rank, or a couple of fancy acronyms before or after it. We get drawn in because someone went to such-and-such university, or grew up in such-and-such a place, or was a student of professor so-and-so. We get drawn in by the idea of someone rather than the actual person themselves. In the same vein, we seem to shut down good ideas not because of the ideas themselves but because of who said them with “rationale” like, “when you’re older,” “when you have more experience,” “when you’ve been here a bit longer,” and “when you’ve paid your dues.”
In this week’s parsha of Yitro (Exodus 18:1-20:23) we see an incredible scene of mentorship take place. Jethro, who is both the father-in-law of Moses and the high priest of Midian, enters the Israelite camp. He observes his son-in-law acting as the sole judge and magistrate for the entire 600,000-person Jewish nation. Jethro pulls Moses aside and tells him, “The thing you are doing is not right; you will surely wear yourself out, and these people as well. For the task is too heavy for you; you cannot do it alone.”[4] He tells Moses to appoint leaders of tens, fifties, hundreds, and thousands who can adjudicate these matters. His counsel helps prevent anarchy and give the people of Israel much needed structure that they will need in order to survive over the next forty years.
I truly shudder to think what would have happened if Moshe Rabbeinu had said something to the effect of, “Well gee Dad, um, that might work over in Midian, but that’s not how we do things here in Israel.”
The blessing of the interaction between Moses and Yitro is two-fold: first Jethro provided wise counsel, and second, Moses listened to it.
The great sage of our people, Maimonides, taught us a simple yet fundamental lesson, “accept the truth from whatever source it proceeds.”[5]
Maybe the best idea in the room will come from the CEO, or maybe it will come from the intern for whom it’s their first day on the job, or maybe it will even come from the janitor.
Bizrat HaShem, may we all possess the humility of Moses to accept great ideas no matter where or who they come from.
Wishing you a Good Shabbos and a great weekend.
Bivrakha,
Rabbi Aaron Stucker-Rozovsky
Beth El Congregation | 520 Fairmont Ave, Winchester, VA 22601
(540) 667-1889 (office)